You send a STEP file to a CNC supplier and write "aluminum" on the RFQ. The parts arrive, and then the bracket bends under load, the housing corrodes in a damp warehouse, or the gear swells and binds. The material was not wrong in general — it was wrong for the job. And "aluminum" never was a specification: 6061-T6, 7075-T6 and 6082-T6 differ in strength, machinability and price, and the temper matters as much as the alloy.
The short answer: choose a CNC material by starting from what the part must survive — load, temperature, chemicals, moisture, wear and electrical behaviour — then narrow to two or three candidate grades and let machinability, tolerance, finish and cost decide between them. For most machined parts the choice is aluminum 6061 for general work, a steel or stainless grade where strength, wear or corrosion demands it, and an engineering plastic such as POM or nylon where weight, insulation or sliding matters. Name the exact grade and temper in the RFQ; a family name is not a specification.
Why Start with the Job, Not the Material?
The most common material mistake is choosing a material before defining the requirement. A buyer who starts from "we always use aluminum" will machine a part that fails in a chemical environment aluminum cannot survive; a buyer who starts from "stainless is safest" will pay for corrosion resistance a dry indoor bracket never needs.
Protolabs, the U.S. manufacturing company, frames the selection the right way round: prioritise the part’s requirements first, starting with the must-haves and working down to the nice-to-haves. Its guide lists six groups to work through before naming any material:
- Environmental: heat and cold, flame retardance, UV and chemical exposure, food-grade or medical-grade requirements, and the full scope of the application — a medical part may have to survive autoclave heat or harsh chemical sterilisation between uses.
- Electrical: the part may need to conduct electricity, insulate against it, or dissipate static. Metals conduct; most plastics insulate.
- Mechanical: strength comes in many forms — tensile, compressive, impact, wear resistance, lubricity for a bearing surface, rigidity or flexibility. Name the load and the failure mode, not just "strong."
- Cosmetic: transparency, colour, surface texture from non-slip to high polish. Cosmetics are secondary for many parts and essential for others.
- Size: part size can be limited by the maximum available size of a particular stock material.
- Cost: important, but it should fall after the must-haves, among the nice-to-haves — a cheap material that fails is the most expensive choice.
How Do the Main CNC Material Families Compare?
The table below compares the materials a CNC supplier is most likely to offer, using relative ratings as published by Protolabs Network. Treat the ratings as a screening guide, not a substitute for a grade datasheet.
| Material | Typical grades | Strength | Machinability | Relative cost | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aluminum 6061 | 6061-T6 | Medium | ★★★★★ | $ | General-purpose brackets, housings, prototypes |
| Aluminum 7075 | 7075-T6 | High | ★★★★ | $$$ | High-strength, lightweight structural parts |
| Mild steel | 1018 | Medium | ★★★ | $$ | General machinery parts, jigs and fixtures |
| Alloy steel | 4140 | Medium | ★★ | $$$ | Shafts, tooling, parts needing heat treatment |
| Stainless steel 304 | 304 / 304L | High | ★★ | $$$ | General corrosion resistance, food and medical use |
| Stainless steel 316 | 316 / 316L | High | ★★ | $$$$ | Chloride, marine and chemical environments |
| Brass | C36000 | Medium | ★★★★★ | $$ | Valves, nozzles, fittings, decorative parts |
| POM (acetal) | POM-C / Delrin | Medium | ★★★★ | $$ | Precision parts, gears, bushings, sliding parts |
| Nylon (PA6/PA66) | PA6, PA66 | High | ★ | $$ | Tough, wear-resistant parts |
| Polycarbonate (PC) | PC | High | ★★ | $$ | Transparent covers, impact-resistant housings |
| PEEK | PEEK | High | ★★ | $$$$ | High temperature, chemical and wear resistance |
Use the relative ratings to make a shortlist. The grade, stock condition, wall stiffness, tool access and finish can change cutting time, so ask for a machining allowance on the actual drawing. For sliding or chemically exposed parts, compare grade-specific wear and compatibility data at the intended temperature before deciding whether a higher-cost polymer pays for itself.
When Does Aluminum Win — and Which Alloy?
Aluminum is the default CNC material for a reason: it is about one-third the density of steel, machines quickly, resists corrosion naturally, and conducts heat and electricity well. For brackets, housings, enclosures, fixtures and prototypes, it is usually the first candidate to test against the requirement list.
Protolabs’ comparison is direct: 6061 offers excellent machinability, low cost and versatility; 7075 offers high strength, hardness, low weight and heat tolerance. In practice:
- 6061-T6 is the general-purpose choice — good strength-to-weight ratio, excellent machinability, weldable, and the cheapest route to a finished part. Choose it unless a specific requirement rules it out.
- 7075-T6 is the high-strength choice — substantially stronger and harder than 6061, and still light. Xometry’s materials guide describes 7075 as high strength, tough, fatigue resistant and very machinable, but it costs more, welds poorly, and needs more attention to corrosion protection than 6061.
- 6082-T6 sits between them for structural work, with very good weldability and thermal conductivity, and is a common structural reference in European supply chains.
Choose a finish for the exposure, contact surfaces and final dimensions. Anodizing can improve wear or corrosion resistance. Specify the coating and thickness with the finisher, and identify electrical contact or grounding faces that need masking or a conductive conversion coating. A colored surface and a low-resistance contact can require different treatments. Danco’s hardcoat dimensional guide illustrates coating growth on external surfaces and in bores. State which dimensions and fits must pass after finishing.
When Do You Need Steel or Stainless Steel?
Steel wins where aluminum cannot: high loads, wear, impact and heat treatment. The price is weight, slower machining, and corrosion protection that aluminum does not need.
- Mild steel (1018, 1020) is the general machinery choice: medium strength, good machinability, low cost, and easy to weld. It rusts without protection, so budget for plating, painting or oiling.
- Alloy steel (4140, 4340) is the choice for shafts, gears and tooling: higher strength and hardness, heat-treatable, but slower to machine and more expensive to finish.
- Stainless steel 304 is the general-purpose corrosion-resistant choice for food, medical and general industrial use. 316 / 316L adds molybdenum and resists chlorides — seawater, some cleaning agents and certain process chemicals — better than 304. If the part will see chlorides, 316L is the recommendation; if it will not, 304 is the cheaper answer to the same question.
- Stainless 303 is the free-machining stainless: it cuts much faster than 304 or 316, at the cost of lower corrosion resistance. It is a good choice for fittings and fasteners that need stainless properties without stainless machining time.
- 17-4PH is a precipitation-hardening stainless that combines high strength with corrosion resistance and can be heat-treated after machining — useful for parts that need both. Note that stainless grades work-harden, so they need sharp tooling, correct speeds and rigid setups; that is why their machinability rating in the table above is low, and why a stainless part of the same geometry costs more to machine than the same part in aluminum.
What About Brass, Copper and Titanium?
Brass (C36000) is the easiest metal to machine in the table, with the highest machinability rating alongside aluminum 6061. It is the natural choice for valves, nozzles, fittings, connectors and decorative parts, and it machines to a good finish without secondary work. Its limits are moderate strength and poor performance in some corrosive environments, where it can dezincify.
Copper (C110) is chosen for one reason: conductivity. It conducts electricity and heat better than any other common CNC metal, which makes it the choice for electrical contacts, heat sinks and bus bars. It is soft, gummy to machine, and expensive — never choose it for structure.
Titanium (Ti-6Al-4V / TC4) is the specialist choice: a strength-to-weight ratio higher than steel at a density of 4.43 g/cm³, excellent corrosion resistance, and biocompatibility for medical implants. It is also slow and expensive to machine and hard on tooling. Choose it only when the requirement list — weight plus strength plus corrosion, or medical use — rules out everything cheaper.
When Is an Engineering Plastic the Right CNC Material?
Machined stock is useful for checking envelope, interfaces and assembly before cutting a production mold. Even with the same resin family, extruded or cast stock can differ from a molded part in orientation, moisture state and residual stress. Validate weld lines, molded shrinkage, fiber direction and production loading on representative molded parts.
- POM (acetal, Delrin) is the most machinable CNC plastic and the standard choice for precision parts: gears, bushings, bearings and sliding components. Protolabs notes its high mechanical strength, good dimensional stability and low moisture absorption. It machines to tight tolerances and a good finish, and it is the first plastic to try when the part must slide or hold a dimension.
- Nylon (PA6, PA66) is tough and wear-resistant, and a good choice for gears and structural plastic parts — but it absorbs moisture, and moisture changes its dimensions. State the measurement condition on the drawing and in the inspection plan.
- Polycarbonate (PC) is the transparent, impact-resistant choice for covers, guards and housings that must be seen through or survive impact. It is sensitive to some chemicals and to stress cracking, so check compatibility with cleaners and solvents the part will meet.
- ABS is the low-cost general plastic for housings and presentation prototypes, with good impact strength and easy machining. It is not a high-temperature or high-load material.
- PEEK and PEI (Ultem) are the high-performance plastics: high temperature, chemical and wear resistance, high strength and stiffness. PEEK offers high abrasion and wear resistance, low moisture absorption and a low coefficient of friction; Ultem offers extreme strength, stiffness and chemical resistance and high dielectric strength. Both are expensive and slow to machine — choose them when the requirement list rules out every cheaper plastic, not before.
A plastic part is not a metal part with a different colour. Plastics are more sensitive to heat, moisture and fixturing stress than metals, and can warp or creep after machining, so a tight tolerance in plastic costs more than the same tolerance in metal. If your part needs tight tolerances in a plastic grade, say so in the RFQ and ask the supplier how they will hold it. Our CNC quoting guide gives the general tolerance defaults for machined plastics and metals, and explains why a tolerance without a datum scheme is an incomplete instruction.
How Do Material, Tolerance and Finish Interact?
A coating narrows an internal bore and increases an external shaft diameter where it builds above the original surface. Removal by polishing has the opposite effect. Ask the finisher for the expected change per surface, mark any masking, and inspect the assembled fit after the specified finish. For a plastic feature, agree the conditioning state and measurement temperature. For a repeatedly loaded thread, compare direct threads with an insert using the assembly torque, expected cycles and pull-out requirement.
What Does the Material Choice Do to the Price?
A CNC supplier prices programming and setup, material, machine time, finishing and inspection — and material choice moves three of them at once. The worked example below shows how, using stated assumptions for a small aluminum bracket machined in three candidate materials. The numbers are illustrative, with stated assumptions, and are not a CKMOLD quotation or a price promise for any real part.
Illustrative example — assumptions: one bracket, roughly 80 × 50 × 20 mm; batch of 100 parts; one-time programming and setup USD 480; inspection USD 2 per part; material blank cost and machine time per part as stated; same drawing and finish at every material.
| Material | Blank cost per part | Machine time per part | Machining cost per part | Total for 100 parts | Unit price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aluminum 6061-T6 | USD 4 | 12 min | USD 16 | USD 2,680 | USD 26.80 |
| Stainless steel 304 | USD 9 | 30 min | USD 40.00 | USD 5,580.00 | USD 55.80 |
| PEEK | USD 38 | 25 min | USD 33.33 | USD 7,813.33 | USD 78.13 |
The example uses USD 80 per machine hour, USD 480 fixed setup and USD 2 inspection per accepted part. For 100 stainless brackets, the total is USD 480 + 100 × (USD 9 blank + USD 40 machining + USD 2 inspection) = USD 5,580. The PEEK row uses the unrounded USD 33⅓ machining charge in the total. Scrap, outside finishing and freight are excluded. Ask suppliers to identify these items and compare quotes at the same accepted quantity.
Quantity changes the picture as well. Programming, fixturing and first-article inspection are largely fixed costs, roughly the same for 10 parts or 500, while material, machine time and per-part inspection scale with quantity. Give the supplier the first order quantity, the expected repeat pattern and an annual estimate, even as a range.
Material Checklist for Your CNC RFQ
| # | Check | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Exact grade and temper named (e.g. 6061-T6, 316L, POM-C) | A family name is not a specification |
| 2 | Requirement list attached (load, temperature, chemicals, moisture, electrical) | The supplier confirms the grade rather than guessing it |
| 3 | Stock condition stated (plate, bar, billet; certificate required?) | Stock form affects price and result |
| 4 | Critical dimensions marked with datum scheme | Tolerances are meaningless without datums |
| 5 | Finish per surface, stated before or after finishing | Finishing changes dimensions |
| 6 | Quantity, repeat pattern and annual estimate given | Fixed setup cost spreads across the batch |
| 7 | Inspection evidence agreed (first article, dimensional report, certificate) | Inspection is scoped work, not a free extra |
| 8 | Alternatives policy stated (prohibited, pre-approved, or subject to validation) | A substitute grade is an engineering change |
If the grade is still open, say which properties drive the choice instead of naming a material — the supplier can then confirm the grade rather than guess it. And if the part will later be injection molded, say so: a machined prototype in the production resin validates fit and assembly, but it does not reproduce molded behaviour such as weld lines and shrinkage. Our comparison of injection molding and CNC machining explains where each process is the right choice for the production part.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I just say "aluminum" and let the supplier choose the alloy?
You can, but you will get the supplier’s default, and defaults differ. One supplier’s default aluminum is 6061-T6; another’s is 6082-T6; a third may quote 7075-T6 for a part that does not need it. If the grade does not matter to the part, say "6061-T6 or equivalent, subject to approval" — that is a specification with a decision in it, not an open question.
Is stainless steel always better than aluminum?
No. Stainless is better for corrosion, wear and high-temperature strength, and worse for weight, machining time, cost and thermal conductivity. A stainless bracket in a dry indoor enclosure is a heavier, slower and more expensive version of an aluminum bracket that would have worked. Choose by the requirement list, not by the reputation of the material.
What to Send With Your RFQ
Send the 3D CAD file (STEP), a 2D drawing with the critical dimensions, datum scheme and general tolerance standard, the exact material grade and temper (or the requirement list if the grade is still open), expected quantities and repeat pattern, the surface finish for each surface that matters, and the inspection evidence you expect.
Request a quote for your CNC machined parts with your drawing, material requirements and quantities, and we will confirm the grade and the inspection plan before quoting.